ENGLISH
REFERENCE

carry coals to Newcastle

idiom
Meaning

To do something that is unneeded or redundant.


Origin

disputed origin

Newcastle upon Tyne (in England) was a major coal-exporting city, so sending coal there would be pointless.

Examples
SIMPLE

Bringing extra food to a feast is like carrying coals to Newcastle.

CONTEXTUAL

Offering advice to an expert on their own subject is just carrying coals to Newcastle.

COMPLEX

By attempting to lecture the seasoned historian on the nuances of the revolution, the student was merely carrying coals to Newcastle.

Anchors to
Related idioms8entries
  1. 01

    can't carry a tune in a bucket

    Sings very badly.

  2. 02

    carry a torch

    To love or to be romantically infatuated with, especially when such feelings are not reciprocated.

  3. 03

    carry away

    To be so excited that one is no longer in control of one's actions or behavior.

  4. 04

    carry forward

    To transfer to a new page, column, ledger, or similar entity.

  5. 05

    carry off

    To act convincingly; to succeed at giving the impression of (e.g.) knowledge, confidence, or familiarity.

  6. 06

    carry on

    To continue or proceed as before.

  7. 07

    carry one's weight

    To contribute or produce one's fair share, as of work, money, etc.

  8. 08

    carry oneself

    To move, especially emphasizing the manner in which one moves.

© 2026 English Reference